The readings for this week included two chapters from the Lifesmart textbook. Chapters 6 and 7 dealt with childhood development during the Early and Middle Childhood years. These periods, lasting roughly from ages 2-6 and 5-12, see children undergoing dramatic changes, both physical and mental. One area of particular importance is moral development of children. During the Middle Childhood years, children begin to develop their own moral views as well as their understanding of why they should not harm others. Although Piaget felt this development was due to the cognitive development of the children, he observed how children responded to rules. His view were later expanded and developed into two varying theories.
The first theory was developed by Lawrence Kohlberg, who felt that children must overcome their ego centrism before they could begin to make moral judgments. Carol Gilligan, on the other hand, felt that this theory focused too extensively on male children for evidence. She, then, developed a theory which focused more on girls and women, called the Ethics of Care. In this view, morality is developed as a result of relationships with others, and morality is determined by how we affect others through our actions.
This justice vs. care dichotomy of morality is drawn along lines of sex, it seems, which may explain how children develop their moral views, but it doesn't take up the question of moral judgments. I believe that understanding this difference in development, however, is a useful tool for teaching young children, as it can give teachers an understanding of what strategies will work best in teaching students right from wrong. It can also be useful for developing classroom rules which can be understood and appreciated by both boys and girls.
I think you have a great summary of the readies and believe we have similar discriptions on the theories. I thank LIFEMSART for those good, easy on the eyes readings to complete assigned by Eric. I do agree that understanding the development stages are very important as a teacher and can be applied in the classroom, and do think that many boys and girls would appreciate their teacher giving them the space to develope those changes and have the correct guidance of someone that does understand how they are making the choices of righty and wrong and what strategies they use to overcome those different directions. Great job!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGlad you focused on Kohlberg's Morality. Many people believe morality just appears and do not realize that it needs to develop like many other elements of ourselves. A great exercise in Kholberg is the Heinz Dilemma https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxJ07klMhr0
ReplyDeleteAndrew,
ReplyDeleteAs a woman and a mother I was drawn more to Gilligan's theory rather than Kohlberg's. I am a nurturer, so the Ethics of Care plays right into my wheelhouse. I did, however, agree with some of Kohlberg's thoughts, but in the end Gilligan won out for me. I am sure that none of this comes as a surprise to you, with our many months spent together in our cohort.
Lisa
Andrew,
ReplyDeleteAs a woman and a mother I was drawn more to Gilligan's theory rather than Kohlberg's. I am a nurturer, so the Ethics of Care plays right into my wheelhouse. I did, however, agree with some of Kohlberg's thoughts, but in the end Gilligan won out for me. I am sure that none of this comes as a surprise to you, with our many months spent together in our cohort.
Lisa
Hey Andrew,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your overview of the chapter and how you want more and dives into Kohlberg's thoughts branching off of Piaget theory as well as Gilligans theory diving into the ethics of care. I think you brought up a very valid point that children need to understand both sides of the theories and how they build morality so that they can learn easier and quicker. This is a helpful tool for teachers to know and maybe difficult for them to think of learning plans that cover both sides of Kohlberg's and Gilligans theories. This goes to show that teachers no matter what need to adapt to the world around them and present both sides of any situation, very interesting point. As a coach I try to understand both sides of every story and every situation so I am fascinated and how to present both sides of their theories!
-Landon